4.4. In which cases is a pedestrian allowed to move along the edge of the carriageway?
UAВ яких випадках пішоходу дозволено рух краєм проїзної частини?
Question without image
This exam question from the Traffic Rules of Ukraine checks basic pedestrian safety in situations where the usual and safest places for walking are absent. A pedestrian stepping onto the roadway always increases the risk of a traffic accident, so the traffic rules clearly define when this is even allowed and how exactly one should act to minimize danger when moving near vehicle traffic.
The question belongs to Section 4 of the Traffic Rules (duties and rights of pedestrians) and is primarily based on point 4.1: the priority is the sidewalk or pedestrian path; if these are absent, movement is allowed on the bicycle path (without interfering with cyclists), next — along the shoulder in a single file. Only when there is no shoulder or it is impossible to walk on it, is it permitted to walk along the edge of the roadway. That is why the correct option combines the conditions "no sidewalk/pedestrian path" and "no shoulder or impossible to walk on it": this is a forced, not a "normal" way of moving.
When analyzing the options, it is important to see that the restriction "only during the day" is not a condition from point 4.1, so the statement about daylight hours does not determine the legality of such movement. Similarly, the requirement for reflectors relates to increasing visibility in the dark and is indeed important for safety, but it is not a criterion that in this exam question "allows or forbids" walking along the edge of the roadway (the permission arises due to the absence of safer road elements). In the theoretical exam, the key is to remember the sequence: sidewalk/path → if necessary, bicycle path → shoulder → edge of the roadway as a last resort, usually facing oncoming traffic (taking into account the exceptions specified in point 4.3).
Clause 4.1
Pedestrians must walk on sidewalks and pedestrian paths, keeping to the right side. If there are no sidewalks, pedestrian paths, or it is impossible to move along them, pedestrians may use bicycle paths, keeping to the right side and not obstructing bicycle traffic, or walk in a single file along the shoulder, keeping as far to the right as possible, and if there is no shoulder or it is impossible to move along it — along the edge of the carriageway facing oncoming traffic. In doing so, they must be cautious and not interfere with other road users.
Clause 4.3
Outside populated areas, pedestrians walking along the shoulder or the edge of the carriageway must walk facing oncoming traffic. Persons moving along the shoulder or the edge of the carriageway in wheelchairs without an engine, or leading a motorcycle, moped, or bicycle, must move in the direction of traffic.
Clause 1.10 (term "Carriageway")
Carriageway — an element of the road intended for the movement of non-rail vehicles.
Clause 1.10 (term "Shoulder")
Shoulder — an element of the road, structurally separated or marked by a solid road marking line, that adjoins the outer edge of the carriageway, is at the same level with it, and is not intended for vehicle movement (except in cases provided for by these Rules).
Thus, the correct answer is "Answers 3 and 4.", considering that according to the definition in the Traffic Rules, a pedestrian is allowed to walk along the edge of the carriageway only in the absence of a shoulder or if it is impossible to walk along it, and in this case, the pedestrian must walk facing oncoming traffic (taking into account the exceptions defined in clause 4.3).
According to the general rule, a pedestrian must move along the sidewalk or pedestrian path, keeping to the right side. These are the main and safest places for pedestrians, so stepping onto the roadway is not the “norm” but is allowed only as a last resort.
The Traffic Rules allow a pedestrian to approach the roadway gradually, depending on the circumstances. If there is no sidewalk or pedestrian path, or it is impossible to use them, then the pedestrian may use the bicycle path (but must walk on the right and not interfere with cyclists). If there is no bicycle path or it is unsuitable for movement, the next option is to move along the shoulder in a single file, as far to the right as possible.
Only when there is no shoulder or it is impossible to move along it, the Traffic Rules allow the pedestrian to move along the edge of the roadway. At the same time, a key safety requirement is established: you must move facing the flow of vehicles, so you can see approaching cars and have the opportunity to react in advance.
For example, if you are walking on a road where there is neither a sidewalk nor a pedestrian path, and the shoulder is washed out or covered with snow and it is impossible to walk on it, then you have the right to walk along the very edge of the roadway, but strictly in the direction opposite to the movement of vehicles and with maximum caution, without creating obstacles.
Therefore, the correct answer is "Answers 3 and 4," since walking along the edge of the roadway is allowed only in the absence of a shoulder or if it is impossible to move along it, and only facing the flow of vehicles.