21.5. In which case is it permitted to transport passengers outside the cab of a vehicle?
UAУ якому випадку дозволено перевозити пасажирів поза кабіною транспортного засобу?
Question without image
This exam question from the Traffic Rules of Ukraine tests knowledge of basic safety requirements when transporting people, as riding outside the vehicle cab is one of the riskiest situations in road traffic. The traffic rules establish a general prohibition on such transportation to prevent passenger injuries in the event of sudden braking, maneuvering, or an accident.
In content, it belongs to Section 21 "Passenger Transportation" and is directly related to clause 21.11 a). In the theoretical exam, it is important to understand that exceptions to the prohibition are very limited: it is allowed to transport passengers outside the cab only when the cargo truck's flatbed is specially equipped for transporting people, or when a van body is used that is specifically designed for passenger transportation. These two options form the correct answer combination.
The analysis of typical options in this exam question is as follows: a flatbed platform and a van body may be permitted only if they are equipped and intended for passengers, while a tractor body is among the explicitly prohibited places. Likewise, the traffic rules prohibit transporting people in a dump truck body, on a cargo trailer or semi-trailer, and in other cases listed in clause 21.11 a), regardless of the trip distance. The practical benefit of this knowledge is simple: it helps quickly distinguish a permitted "specially equipped place for passengers" from any other dangerous transportation outside the cab.
Clause 21.11 a) (Section 21 "Carriage of Passengers")
"It is prohibited to carry passengers: a) passengers outside the cab of a car (except for the cases provided by these Rules for carrying passengers in the body of a flatbed truck or in a van body designed for passenger transport), in the body of a dump truck, tractor, other self-propelled machines, on a cargo trailer, semi-trailer, in a trailer-cottage, in the body of a cargo motorcycle."
Application: this clause directly establishes a general prohibition on carrying passengers outside the cab, but at the same time defines exceptions when it is allowed: in the body of a flatbed truck or in a van body, if it is designed for passenger transport.
That is, the correct answer is "Answers 1 and 2.", given that according to the definition of the Traffic Rules, carrying passengers outside the cab is prohibited, except in cases of transport in the body of a flatbed truck or in a van body designed for passenger transport.
The Traffic Rules of Ukraine are based on a general principle: passengers must be transported in the cab or in places specifically designed for this purpose by the vehicle's construction. Therefore, transporting people outside the cab is usually prohibited, as it is dangerous and does not provide proper protection for passengers.
At the same time, item 21.11 (a) makes a clear exception to this prohibition. It is allowed to transport passengers outside the cab only in two cases: in the body of a flatbed truck (when such transportation is permitted by the Rules) or in a van body that is specifically designed for passenger transportation. This refers to situations where the body is structurally and organizationally adapted for people, and not used as a random place for a ride.
To understand the limits of what is allowed, it is also important to remember the opposite: it is not permitted to transport passengers outside the cab in the body of a dump truck, tractor, other self-propelled machines, on a cargo trailer or semi-trailer, in a camper trailer, or in the body of a cargo motorcycle. For example, riding in the body of a dump truck or sitting on a cargo trailer while moving is prohibited regardless of the distance.
Therefore, the correct answer is "Answers 1 and 2," since the Traffic Rules allow the transportation of passengers outside the cab only in the body of a flatbed truck (in cases provided by the Rules) or in a van body specifically designed for passenger transportation.