8.1.82. If the traffic controller's signal differs from the traffic light signal, will you follow the signals of the traffic controller?
UAЯкщо сигнал регулювальника відрізняється від сигналу світлофора, Ви будете керуватись сигналами регулювальника:
Question without image
This is an exam question from the Traffic Rules of Ukraine concerning the safe organization of traffic at controlled intersections, where both a traffic light and a police officer directing traffic may be present at the same time. In real-life situations, such cases arise during traffic jams, accidents, roadworks, or traffic light outages, so the ability to correctly determine signal priority directly affects safety and helps avoid violations.
The question tests knowledge from Section 8 of the Traffic Rules, specifically the regulation of road traffic and priority of control. According to clause 8.3, the signals of the traffic controller take precedence over traffic light signals and priority signs, and are mandatory for all road users. That is why it is important to remember for the theoretical exam: if there is a discrepancy between what the traffic light shows and what the controller requires, you must follow the instructions of the controller.
The analysis of the answer options here is straightforward: the option "Yes" corresponds to clause 8.3, because the controller has higher priority and effectively "overrides" conflicting traffic light signals. The option "No" is incorrect, as ignoring the controller's gestures leads to improper passage through the intersection, conflict situations, and liability for traffic violations, even if the traffic light at that moment is showing a permissive signal.
Clause 8.1
Traffic regulation is carried out using road signs, road markings, traffic lights, and traffic controller signals.
Brief application: the clause specifies that different means of regulation, such as traffic lights and a traffic controller, may be used simultaneously on the road/intersection.
Clause 8.3
Traffic controller signals take precedence over traffic light signals and the requirements of priority road signs and are mandatory for all road users.
Brief application: if the signals of the traffic controller differ from those of the traffic lights, the driver must follow the signals of the traffic controller, as they have higher priority.
That is, the correct answer is "Yes," given that according to the Traffic Rules, the signals of the traffic controller take precedence over traffic light signals and are mandatory for compliance.
When both a traffic light is operating at an intersection and a traffic controller is present on the road, such an intersection is considered regulated. In this situation, it is important to understand that, in fact, only one "controlling" signal governs the movement, and that is the gestures and position of the traffic controller.
According to paragraph 8.3 of the Traffic Rules of Ukraine, the signals of a traffic controller who is directing traffic are mandatory for all road users and take precedence over traffic light signals and priority signs. That is, if there is a discrepancy between what the traffic light shows and what the controller requires, the driver must act according to the controller's instructions.
For example, if the traffic light shows green but the controller raises their hand up (a signal that prohibits movement and requires stopping), you are required to stop, even despite the "permission" of the traffic light. Or vice versa: the traffic light may show red, but the controller's position and gesture allow movement in a certain direction—in that case, movement is permitted according to the controller's signal.
Therefore, the correct answer is "Yes," because according to paragraph 8.3 of the Traffic Rules, the signals of the traffic controller take precedence over traffic light signals, and in case of a discrepancy, the requirements of the controller must be followed.