8.1.73. In which place must the driver stop their vehicle when a prohibitory traffic light signal is on or the traffic controller raises their hand upwards?
UAУ якому місці водій повинен зупинити свій транспортний засіб у разі ввімкнення заборонного сигналу світлофора або підняття регулювальником руки вгору?
Question without image
This is an exam question from the Traffic Rules of Ukraine about safe stopping before an intersection or pedestrian crossing when movement is prohibited by a traffic light signal or a traffic controller's signal (in particular, a raised hand). The correct choice of stopping place directly affects safety: if you stop "in the wrong place," the driver may end up on the crossing, enter the intersection, block visibility, or create an obstacle for pedestrians and cross traffic.
In essence, this checks the section of the traffic rules regarding traffic light and controller signals and compliance with their requirements, as well as knowledge of marking 1.12 (stop line) and the informational sign 5.69 "Stopping Place." In the theoretical exam, it is important to understand the sequence from point 8.10 of the Traffic Rules: the driver stops before the stop line, if it is present; if there is no stop line—before the "Stopping Place" sign; if there is neither marking nor sign—before the traffic light or before the pedestrian crossing (and if these are absent—before the intersected carriageway), without creating obstacles for pedestrians.
Therefore, each of the reference points listed in the options is correct, but is applied depending on what exactly is present on the road at a particular location: the stop line has the highest priority, next is sign 5.69, and in their absence, the driver chooses to stop before the traffic light or crossing so as not to enter a dangerous area. It is precisely because of this "sequence" that the traffic rules combine several correct formulations into one answer, which this exam question checks.
Clause 8.10
In case a traffic light (except a reversible one) or a traffic controller gives a signal prohibiting movement, drivers must stop before road marking 1.12 (stop line), road sign 5.69 "Stopping place"; if these are absent — no closer than 10 m from the nearest rail before a railway crossing, before the traffic light, pedestrian crossing, and if these are also absent and in all other cases — before the intersected carriageway, without creating obstacles for pedestrians.
Brief application: the clause establishes the sequence for choosing a stopping place at a prohibitive traffic light signal or a prohibitive signal from the traffic controller (including when the controller raises their hand up): first the stop line 1.12, then sign 5.69, and if both are absent — other specified places (before the crossing/traffic light/crosswalk/intersected carriageway).
Clause 34.1 — 34 "Road markings", 1 "Horizontal markings", marking 1.12 (stop line)
Marking 1.12 (stop line) — indicates the place where the driver must stop in the presence of sign 2.2, at a prohibitive traffic light signal (except a reversible one) or from a traffic controller.
Brief application: if marking 1.12 is applied before an intersection/crosswalk, stopping at "prohibited" is done precisely before this line.
Clause 33.5 — 33 "Road signs", 5 "Information and direction signs", sign 5.69 "Stopping place"
Sign 5.69 "Stopping place" — indicates the place where vehicles must stop at a prohibitive traffic light signal or from a traffic controller.
Brief application: if there is no stop line, but sign 5.69 is installed, the driver stops before this sign (at the place it indicates).
Thus, the correct answer is "Answers 1, 2, and 3.", considering that according to the definition of the Traffic Rules (clause 8.10), the driver at a prohibitive signal is obliged to stop at the specified places in the established order: before stop line 1.12, before sign 5.69, and if both are absent — before other designated landmarks (traffic light/pedestrian crossing/intersected carriageway), without creating obstacles for pedestrians.
When a traffic light shows a prohibitive signal or a traffic controller raises their hand up, it means one thing for the driver: movement must be stopped. However, it is important not just to stop, but to do so in the correct place, so as not to create danger or interfere with other road users.
Clause 8.10 of the Traffic Rules establishes the sequence by which the driver chooses the stopping place. First of all, you must stop before the stop line (marking 1.12), if it is present. This is the most unambiguous reference point: the stop line specifically marks the boundary beyond which you cannot proceed when the signal is prohibitive.
If there is no stop line, the next reference point is road sign 5.69 "Stopping Place." It indicates the spot where the vehicle must stop, for example, before an intersection or before a traffic light in places with limited visibility or special traffic organization.
When there is neither a stop line nor a "Stopping Place" sign, the driver must stop so as not to enter dangerous or priority areas: before the traffic light or before the pedestrian crossing, without obstructing pedestrians. And if there are no such reference points, then the stop is made before the intersecting carriageway (that is, before the boundaries of the intersection), again without creating obstacles for pedestrians.
Thus, the correct answer is "Answers 1, 2, and 3," since clause 8.10 of the Traffic Rules defines several possible stopping places depending on the presence of a stop line, a "Stopping Place" sign, and other reference points, and all three options correspond to this sequence.