52.66. Is the transportation of organized groups of children allowed during hours of darkness?
UAЧи дозволено перевезення організованих груп дітей у темну пору доби?
Question without image
This exam question from the Traffic Rules of Ukraine concerns passenger safety and, in particular, the heightened requirements for transporting organized groups of children. Such trips carry increased responsibility, as they involve simultaneously transporting a significant number of minors, and at night the risks on the road rise due to poorer visibility and more challenging navigation conditions.
The question tests knowledge of Section 21 of the Traffic Rules, which regulates passenger transportation, specifically clause 21.11 (d). In the Traffic Rules, the term "transportation of organized groups of children" means transporting 10 or more children with an accompanying supervisor, and "nighttime" is defined as the period from sunset to sunrise (clause 1.10). For these conditions, the rules establish a direct prohibition: transporting organized groups of children at night is not allowed, regardless of the type of vehicle or the route.
The analysis of the options in this theoretical exam boils down to understanding that "allowed" and "allowed only in populated areas" contradict the direct provision of clause 21.11 (d) of the Traffic Rules of Ukraine. The restriction is not tied to the category of road or the location of travel, so attempting to "soften" the rule with a condition about populated areas is incorrect. In practice, this means that planning the departure or arrival of a group of children must take into account the time of sunset; otherwise, the transportation will be a violation of the traffic rules.
Clause 21.11 (Section 21 "Carriage of Passengers")
It is prohibited to transport: … g) organized groups of children during hours of darkness.
Explanation of application: this subparagraph directly establishes a ban on the transportation of organized groups of children during hours of darkness, regardless of the type of vehicle and driving conditions.
Clause 1.10 (term "Carriage of organized groups of children")
Carriage of organized groups of children — simultaneous transportation of ten or more children with a supervisor responsible for accompanying them during the trip (for a group of thirty or more children, an additional medical worker is assigned).
Explanation of application: defines what is considered an "organized group of children" (10 or more children with an accompanying supervisor), for which the prohibition from clause 21.11 d) applies.
Clause 1.10 (term "Hours of darkness")
Hours of darkness — the part of the day from sunset to sunrise.
Explanation of application: defines the time limits within which the prohibition from clause 21.11 d) applies.
Thus, the correct answer is "Prohibited.", given that according to the definition in the Traffic Rules, the carriage of organized groups of children (10 or more children with an accompanying supervisor) during hours of darkness (from sunset to sunrise) is directly prohibited by clause 21.11 d).
Under the Traffic Rules, “transportation of organized groups of children” means the simultaneous transportation of ten or more children together with a supervisor who is responsible for accompanying them during the trip. And “dark hours” refers to the period from sunset to sunrise.
Next, let’s refer to paragraph 21.11 of the Traffic Rules of Ukraine, which directly establishes prohibitions during the transportation of passengers. In subparagraph (g) of this paragraph, it is clearly stated that the transportation of organized groups of children during dark hours is not allowed. That is, if the group falls under the definition of “organized” and the trip takes place between sunset and sunrise, such a trip is not permitted according to the rules.
For example: if a bus is transporting a class of 20 students with a supervisor, and the trip is planned after sunset or the arrival is to be at night, this will be considered the transportation of an organized group of children during dark hours, and therefore a violation of the requirements of paragraph 21.11 (d) of the Traffic Rules.
Therefore, the correct answer is “Prohibited,” since paragraph 21.11 (d) of the Traffic Rules of Ukraine directly prohibits the transportation of organized groups of children during dark hours.