20.13. How should you act in a situation when, as you approach a railway crossing, you see an approaching train, but the railway crossing's audible and visual signals are not activated?
UAЯк ви повинні вчинити в ситуації, коли при під'їзді до залізничного переїзду ви побачили поїзд, що наближається, але при цьому звукова та світлова сигналізація залізничного переїзду не увімкнена?
Question without image
This exam question from the Traffic Rules of Ukraine concerns road safety at one of the most dangerous points on the road — a railway crossing. Such situations test whether a driver can make decisions not “prompted” by technology, but based on the actual road situation, since a mistake near the tracks can have the gravest consequences. For the theoretical exam, it is important to understand: actual danger takes priority, not just the operation of the signaling system.
The question checks knowledge of Section 20 of the Traffic Rules, in particular paragraph 20.5 (e), which directly prohibits crossing the railway if a train (locomotive, railcar) is approaching within visible range. The very fact that a train is approaching is an unconditional reason to prohibit crossing, regardless of whether the light and sound signals are working. Therefore, the option to continue driving is incorrect: it ignores the direct rule of the Traffic Code and creates a risk of driving in front of a train due to possible automation failure. The correct action is to stop at the designated place before the crossing and wait until the train passes and it is safe to cross the tracks.
The practical takeaway for students: at a railway crossing, the driver must always additionally assess the situation independently, even if the signaling system is “silent.” This is a typical trap in theoretical exam tasks: the traffic rules require you to be guided not by the assumption that the system is working, but by actual visibility and the approach of a train, which ensures the highest level of safety.
Clause 20.5 (e) (Section 20 "Movement through railway crossings")
Movement through the crossing is prohibited if: (e) a train (locomotive, railcar) is approaching the crossing within visible range.
Application to the question: even if the sound and light signals at the crossing are not activated, the very fact that a train is approaching within visible range is an unconditional reason to prohibit movement through the crossing, therefore the driver must stop and not continue driving.
Clause 1.10 (term "Railway crossing")
Railway crossing — the intersection of a road with railway tracks at the same level.
Application to the question: the situation concerns exactly the section of the road which, according to the Traffic Rules, is a "railway crossing", and therefore special requirements of Section 20 apply to the driver, in particular the prohibition of movement in the presence of an approaching train.
That is, the correct answer is "Stop at the designated place, as crossing the railway is prohibited," given that according to the definition in the Traffic Rules, movement through a railway crossing is directly prohibited if a train is approaching the crossing within visible range, regardless of the operation of light or sound signals.
A railway crossing is a place where a road intersects with railway tracks at the same level, so any driver error here can have the most serious consequences. That is why the rules establish prohibitions that apply regardless of whether the signaling is working or not.
Clause 20.5 of the Traffic Rules of Ukraine explicitly states that crossing the railway is prohibited if a train (locomotive, railcar) is approaching the crossing within visible range. That is, the very fact that you see a train approaching is already sufficient grounds to prohibit crossing. In this situation, you should not “rely” on the absence of light or sound signals, because they may not work due to malfunction or other technical reasons.
In practice, it looks like this: you approach the crossing, see a train approaching, but the signaling is silent. Despite this, you are obliged to act according to the rule that ensures safety: stop at the designated place before the crossing and do not proceed until the train has passed and you are sure that the crossing is safe to cross.
Therefore, the correct answer is "Stop at the designated place, as crossing the railway is prohibited," because according to clause 20.5 (e) of the Traffic Rules, movement is already prohibited due to the fact that a train is approaching the crossing within visible range, regardless of whether the signaling is working.